The New Era of Performance Management: Avoiding Bias While Embracing AI
An employee has a strong year, then makes one mistake right before their review. How much weight does that mistake get? Without regular feedback and documentation, probably more than it should.
In this HRCI webinar, BambooHR HR consultants Nya James and Marissa Smith discuss where bias enters performance reviews and how AI can help managers prepare for fairer conversations. They share practical ways to make performance management more consistent while keeping people responsible for the decisions.
Key takeaways:
- Build trust with clear expectations, regular feedback, and consistent performance conversations throughout the year.
- Reduce bias by documenting results, gathering multiple perspectives, and aligning managers on what good performance looks like.
- Use AI to organize feedback and prepare for conversations while keeping people responsible for decisions.
- Train managers to make coaching and employee development part of their everyday work.
Webinar Transcript
Sarah Richardson
My name is Sarah Richardson. I'm the manager of business development and partnerships here at HRCI. Very happy to be with you all today. Today's webinar topic, it's a good one, "The New Era of Performance Management: Avoiding Bias While Embracing AI." I am so excited to introduce you to today's speakers, Nya James and Marissa Smith. Nya is an HR consultant at BambooHR, where she partners with leaders and HR teams to solve people challenges, improve processes, and build workplaces where employees thrive.
With an MBA in HR management and over five years of HR experience across internal leadership and consulting roles, Nya brings a practical, business-focused approach to HR strategy, compliance, and culture. Welcome, Nya. It's so great to have you here today.
Nya James
Thank you, Sarah.
Sarah Richardson
Yes, and Marissa, who brings over ten years of HR expertise, having grown her career from recruiter to HR business partner to HR director. She now channels her experience and passion into her role as an HR consultant. Her background spans multiple industries, including several years in cybersecurity, hospitality, and now BambooHR. Outside of work, Marissa is a self-proclaimed foodie who enjoys spending time outdoors with her kids and caring for her many pets, including an axolotl. Nya, Marissa, it's wonderful to have you both here with us today.
I'm gonna turn it over to you now so you all can take it from here, and thank you so much. It's great to have you.
Marissa Smith
Thank you, Sarah. Hi everybody, welcome to our webinar today. We are so excited to just hang out with you guys for the next hour. We have a ton of great content and stories to share with you. Intros again, I'm Marissa Smith and Nya is joining me for this. We will get going. Okay, today we're going to cover three things. First, what is changing in performance management and where bias commonly shows up. Next, we're going to look at how AI can help managers prepare for better, objective conversations.
And finally, we're gonna end with a few practical steps that your HR team can take right away to put these ideas into practice.
Nya James
Alrighty, Marissa, I'm gonna dive right in.
Marissa Smith
Yeah.
Nya James
First, I wanna start with the basics. Let's talk about the purpose of performance management. So a lot of HR leaders, we think of performance management as critical for both employees and the business. Not only does it help employees get the right feedback so they can level up their skills, it also helps the organization as a whole improve. I've seen increased productivity and innovation across the businesses that implement this. Yeah. I do want to share an example of a client, Marissa. I'm sure you've seen the same. I've worked with an organization.
They were growing super quickly and leadership came to me like, we have a retention problem. We don't know what to do. But when they started surveying employees, having those real conversations, we heard something completely different. Their employees weren't leaving because they didn't like the company. They were leaving because they didn't know how to grow there. They weren't getting regular feedback. They weren't clear on expectations, and they didn't know what success looked like.
Once the organization took the time to strengthen their performance management process, managers were able to have more meaningful conversations about goals, development, and clear career paths. Employees felt more supported, managers had better visibility, and leadership had better information to make decisions, whether that's, compensation-related or career-level up. So what I think is modern performance management creates value across the organization. For employees, again, clear conversations, expectations, and development.
For managers, coaching is easier, improvement with documentation, and then for the business, better decisions, improved retention, and clear alignment for organizational goals. But I know it's easy to get wrong. So here is the top three issues that we've had— we've identified with the performance management process. First, expectations aren't applied consistently from manager to manager. Evaluations rely too much on memory instead of ongoing consistent documentation. And the process becomes an administrative exercise instead of a coaching conversation. It becomes another task.
These are exactly the type of problems that AI can help reduce, not replace. Marissa, anything you wanna add here with the top three or anything that comes immediately to mind?
Marissa Smith
Yeah, I would just say when it comes down to expectations for managers, this is really where HR, in my opinion, needs to shine and just check in, make sure managers are creating like a streamlined process for all employees. So a good example, standardized questions, right? So the exact same questions for every individual. And you're— by doing this, you're basically giving all employees the exact same experience.
Nya James
Awesome. I definitely agree. And let's pull some data to back it up. I know we have some data freaks in here who love to see.
Marissa Smith
Always.
Nya James
I'm one of them. I love metrics that backs up important insights. So yeah, here are a few. These next few slides come directly from BambooHR, a survey we did on our customers. It helped us understand just how critical performance management really is. So first, we see that a more effective performance management system helps improve employee and business outcomes. We see 40% more employee engagement, 25% less employee turnover, and 15% increase in productivity. Plus, we see serious time savings. So this is a huge number for you guys to swallow.
Managers spend an average of 210 hours every year on performance management. Yeah. 210, Marissa, that's huge.
Marissa Smith
That is a big number.
Nya James
With a better strategy, you can honestly spend 80% less time. Employees spend 40 hours per year on performance management. And with a better strategy or program in place, that time can cut in half. For HR folks on the call, the time savings is even greater than 90% less time spent on the process.
Marissa Smith
Yeah.
Nya James
I'm currently working at the organization where performance review season felt like an all-hands emergency. HR was scrambling to send reminder emails, managers were tracking down forms, employees weren't sure what they had to do or what to complete, and everyone was working from spreadsheets and PDFs, which gives me the icks. By the time all the paperwork was collected, HR had spent weeks just administering the process instead of helping leaders have intentional performance conversations. When they moved into an HRIS, everything changed. Goals, check-ins, reminders, reviews, they all lived in one place.
So HR stopped acting like project managers chasing paperwork and spent their time analyzing trends and coaching managers. So that's really what these numbers represent. The time savings aren't about doing less performance management. It's about spending less time on that administration and more time on your people. I love that.
Marissa Smith
All right, we're going to get going on our next action here. So let's dive in and talk about why performance management has changed so much in the last few years. So most organizations recognize that the traditional performance review process no longer reflects how work actually gets done. So work changes quickly. Employees contribute across teams. Managers are responsible for more people than ever before, yet so many organizations still are relying on those annual reviews, feedback from a single manager, and then manual documentation.
So the result is feedback that comes way too late, a limited view of employee contributions, and then, like Nya mentioned, less time for meaningful coaching.
Nya James
People get lost for sure.
Marissa Smith
Yes. So performance management only works if employees actually trust the process. And trust is a huge word in, this presentation today. So yet nearly three out of four workers say they don't confidently trust how their performance is evaluated. This is going to create skepticism, reduce engagement, and it's going to make feedback less effective overall. So building a more consistent, transparent process is essential for earning that trust. And I think, Nye, you had a good example for this slide.
Nya James
Yeah, for sure. So one of the biggest reasons I see trust breakdown— some of you might be triggered, but organizations keep changing the performance management process without being clear about why. So one year you might have annual reviews. The next, it's quarterly check-ins. Your ratings disappear. Then they come back. From the employee perspective, it can feel like the process is constantly changing, but the experience isn't actually improving.
When that happens, your employees start treating the performance management process as a compliance exercise or just another task on their to-do list versus a development opportunity for them to grow with the organization. They'll think, "I'll complete the form because I have to," rather than "this conversation is going to help me grow and progress in my professional development." So that's why I'd say it's important to be intentional. Marissa, you might hear me say this a lot. Intentional. We don't want to just redesign the process just because it's a trend or, you just want something new.
You want to design it around the experience your employees have and managers have. Communicate why you're making the change and then stick with it long enough for people to build confidence in the process.
Marissa Smith
I love that so much. That's great. Yeah, intentional and trust is what you guys are going to hear a lot of today. Okay, so annual reviews. Let's talk about annual reviews. They were built for a different era of work, like, let's be honest. And today, organizations need a more continuous approach that captures feedback throughout the year documents contributions as they actually happen, incorporates multiple perspectives, and keeps the focus on growth instead of just that once a year evaluation. So managers should still be having their biweekly or monthly one-on-one meetings.
This way employees are going to know where they stand every single month or every two weeks, and that's going to lead up to their yearly performance review. And ultimately, this is basically gonna give them a chance to correct any issues along the way instead of just getting that end of year boom. They had no idea that they were underperforming, or they had no idea that you were considering, giving them a pay increase, a title change, moving them up, moving them down. And basically it's gonna give them a chance to correct everything when it comes down to those increases at the end of the year.
So I like to kind of think of it that way. Yes. And the reality is simple, right? Performance management is supposed to be driving growth, not just your own rating or someone else's rating. So it's a good idea to keep in mind these three things, especially number one. So clear expectations should be set from the very beginning. And the best way to do this is with that job description. They should fully understand what role they're getting into, what's expected of them. Every bullet point that's listed in their job description, they should understand.
So employees should be able to follow the duties within that to ensure that they are keeping on track.
Nya:
I love that, Marissa, because a lot of the times job descriptions are only considered in the hiring process. Yeah, it's the offer sent out. The job description is then lost in the work. So I love that you brought that up.
Marissa Smith
Yeah. I think, a lot of my clients, I'm telling them to just make everyone's job description accessible from day one to the employee so that they can go back and use that as a guide. So if anything, if anyone takes away anything that I say today, please take that away. All right, so many performance challenges aren't people problems, they're really process problems. Feedback is delayed until review time, and managers rely on memory instead of documentation and employees don't consistently receive the coaching that they need.
So as a result, high performers can often be overlooked and development conversations lose momentum. And all of these gaps are gonna create more than inefficiency, right? They also create opportunities for bias to come in, which we're gonna dive deep into. And creating opportunities for bias is gonna influence performance decisions 100%. This is gonna lead us perfectly into our next section where we are gonna talk about how to reduce bias. So Nya, walk us through one of your favorite things.
Nya James
I was just gonna say, I call dibs on this section because this is one of my favorite topics. So let's talk about how better performance practices can actually reduce bias, and then we'll get into how AI can help too. Awesome.
Marissa Smith
Let's do this.
Nya James
Awesome. So let's dive into it. Most bias starts long before tech even enters the process. Even your well-intentioned managers can create inconsistent outcomes through different expectations, limited visibility into employees' work, recency effects, or the language they use to describe performance. I'm gonna choose maybe two of these biases just because, again, these are the two most popular that I had discussions with HR professionals. So let's start with recency bias.
Imagine that an employee consistently exceeds expectations for 11 months in the cycle, but right before their annual review, they make one high-profile mistake. If the manager hasn't documented their accomplishments or had regular check-ins throughout the year, like Marissa mentioned, the one-on-ones, that recent event is likely to carry way more weight than it should. And again, that's not intentional. It's just human nature. Another one that I like to talk about is visibility bias. So this is very popular for some employees who are more vocal versus not.
So let's say you have an employee who speaks up in every meeting or works in the office. They may be perceived as contributing more versus someone who's more quiet or reserved, or if they work remotely. Even if they're delivering the same or even better results, managers don't have that objective information, and outcomes can unintentionally influence performance decisions. So these biases often start way before AI is even involved. If the information goes into the process incomplete or biased, AI can only work with what it's given, what the input that's put in.
That's why getting the process right has to come before even introducing the technology. And then when AI enters the process, it won't remove those inputs, it inherits them. So that's why improving this process is just as important as choosing the right technology. Alright, so we're gonna talk about four ways you can make performance more objective. This is one of my favorite slides, so feel free to document these four. Performance conversations should focus on observable results and behaviors, not just subjective traits. Instead of evaluating whether someone has executive presence or They seem like a natural leader.
Define what success actually looks like and measure against those expectations. So an example for me, I've seen managers equate working long hours or overtime with being a high performer, which I am here to correct.
Marissa Smith
Yeah, I agree.
Nya James
One employee was always online late into the evening, while another consistently finished projects on time during normal business hours. When we looked at the actual outcomes, that second employee was delivering stronger results, and that's a good reminder. Performance should be measured by impact and results, not just by visibility or the hours worked. Number two, one of the easiest ways to reduce bias is to document performance throughout the year. Again, we've been talking about documentation a whole lot, but as HR professionals, we know that's our number one tool.
Regular notes, coaching conversations, Project outcomes and accomplishments create a more accurate picture than relying on your memory during review season. I can speak for myself. I have the memory of a fish. So I document everything. Third is no single person sees everything an employee contributes. Your manager is not over your shoulder throughout, nine to five. Let's combine manager's observations, employee self-reflections, goal progress, and other relevant inputs to create a more complete and balanced view of performance. So I remember a manager I worked with who rated an employee as simply meeting expectations.
But when we looked at the employee's self-assessment, their reflection, their peer feedback, customer feedback, we got a very different picture of meeting expectations. Colleagues consistently highlighted how often that employee stepped in to mentor others and solve cross-functional problems. Things a manager hasn't seen. sometimes employees don't like to brag about what they've done. So those additional perspectives lead to a much more balanced evaluation. Last here is even great managers interpret performance differently.
So calibration helps leaders align on what good performance looks like before evaluations even begin. So that consistency improves fairness, increased trust. Again, Marissa, trust. And makes performance conversations much more objective. So once these practices are in place, AI becomes much more valuable because it's working from those stronger inputs instead of trying to compensate for weak processes.
Marissa Smith
Yeah, I love everything that Nya just said, and I hope you guys definitely took something from that. I know I did. Now we're gonna dive into AI, which is the topic, these last few months, but let's get into the AI aspect of how it better fits into performance management. So the most effective role for AI is as an assistant. So not the decision maker. So keep that in mind, not the decision maker, but more of an assistant. It can collect notes, identify patterns, summarize information, and help managers prepare for better performance conversations.
But just remember, managers still need to go in and apply the context, coach the employees, and make final decisions because as we know, AI cannot do that. AI can improve consistency and save hours and hours of time, but accountability needs to stay with the people. A quick note about using AI in performance management. Organizations aren't adopting AI because performance management is broken. Right? They're adopting AI because managers have less time. They're getting larger teams and more documentation than ever before. So the key is learning how to use it effectively, and then of course without bias.
So let's take a look at the role of AI in a more tangible way just here with this table. So a simple way to think about AI is that it should reduce admin work, not replace human judgment. AI can help draft goals, summarize feedback, identify patterns, and suggest language or even development ideas. Managers again are going to be the ones remaining responsible for setting those expectations, going in and providing the context, coaching the employees, making final performance decisions. The technology supports the process. But again, people remain accountable for the outcomes.
And Nye, I think you had another story for this one as well.
Nya James
Yeah, so Marissa is going to go into a few use cases a bit later, but one example I like is using AI before a performance review. So imagine you're a manager who has a year's worth of one-on-one notes, project updates, and feedback. Instead of spending hours or your full day piecing everything together, AI can summarize those notes and compare them to the employee's goals or job description, highlighting where they've consistently met or exceeded expectations and where they may need development opportunities. But important to note, that's where AI job ends.
As the manager, you still have to add the context, validate the information, and have the conversation with the employee. So AI is gonna help you organize the evidence. But it's not gonna decide the rating for you.
Marissa Smith
Yeah. And really just think of AI as your manager's chief of staff. So it organizes information, prepares the summaries, and surfaces patterns so that managers can spend more time doing the coaching with the employees instead of just compiling notes and trying to find everything. So when people talk about AI bias, which it does happen a lot, and you'll notice kind of if you're just playing around with AI, They often focus on the model itself, but research shows bias actually enters much earlier. So first, AI learns from historical data, which may reflect past inconsistencies or just inequities.
So second, bias can be introduced through the way organizations define and measure performance. If you optimize for visibility instead of impact, AI will reinforce that definition. And third, humans influence AI throughout the process by deciding what data to collect, how to frame the prompts, how to interpret the results, and then ultimately what decisions to make. So AI doesn't eliminate bias on its own. It's gonna reflect the process that it's given. So this is why, all right, good governance leads to better AI outcomes. So AI is strongest at again, pattern recognition and preparation, not the evaluation.
So that means people should always make the final decisions. AI should only work from documented and reliable information, and organizations should regularly review the outputs to ensure that they're fair, accurate, and aligned with those expectations. So governance isn't about limiting AI, it's about making AI trustworthy, building the trust. Strong governance helps employees trust both the technology and the decisions that are gonna come from it. So a good way to keep this on track, make sure you guys have a policy that employees can reference for this, and you can build a simple one using AI.
All right, so we're gonna put some of this knowledge into good use. So here are some AI prompts that you could give your managers to use today. So we're gonna take a look at those. All right, so feedback, synthesis. You can ask it to summarize the themes from these notes and identify coaching topics. That's a really good one. Conversation prep. You can create 5 discussion questions based on the documented performance. You could go into development planning, so you could ask it, suggest growth actions aligned to these goals and name a few goals.
They could be personal, professional, they could be tied into, company goals. Or you can do a bias check. So you can say, identify subjective language and recommend more objective alternatives. And one thing I like to always mention is when you're doing any of this in AI, make sure that before you use AI to help document anything, that you do have a second pair of eyes. Just glance it over. Because if you're not familiar with the multiple different biases, they can sneak in there.
And then the, the paperwork and the forms that you're going to give to the employees could be misconstrued, and there could be one tiny thing that snuck in there. So I always say, and my team's great at this, like, we'll just have each other review things before we send it out. So that is totally fine. Better to be safe than sorry.
Nya James
Awesome. Thanks, Marissa. I want to quickly move on to talk about how to build a continuous performance management process. So here's where it gets more actionable for you all. The biggest shift for building a continuous performance management process isn't replacing your managers with AI. That is not what we're trying to say today. It's replacing one high-pressure annual event to lightweight habits throughout the entire year. Frequent recognition, regular check-ins, and ongoing development conversations create better data, better coaching, and better outcomes.
I think we chatted about this a bit, Marissa, but the weekly and monthly is just as important as the quarterly or biannually.
Marissa Smith
Yeah, 100%.
Nya James
So AI helps support each step by organizing the information and preparing managers while the conversations and decisions remain human. So better comp performance conversations don't happen because your managers have better intentions. They happen because your managers have better systems. We haven't talked about the systems behind your managers. So first, they need the right tools, those templates, documentation, and AI to reduce administrative work. And those should be planned ahead of time. It shouldn't be, right when reviews are about to be conducted that managers get this information.
First, they need the right—second, they need processes that create regular check-ins instead of relying on the annual reviews. Third, we mentioned this quite a bit, but clear expectations so managers have a shared understanding of what good feedback and performance looks like.
Marissa Smith
Yeah.
Nya James
Finally, they need coaching. So even the best tools and processes won't improve performance if managers aren't trained and reinforced over time. So when these four elements start to work together, performance conversations become more consistent more objective, and more valuable for your employees. So increases engagement overall. Alright, so this statistic reinforces why performance management has to be about development and not just evaluation.
So if only 7% of HR leaders believe employees already have the capabilities needed for future priorities, then every performance conversation should help build new skills, not simply assess past performance. AI can help managers identify development opportunities, but your managers are still responsible for coaching employees and supporting their growth over time.
Marissa Smith
All right, thanks, Nya. Yeah, again, super important. if you can take away that managers still need to be the main process, the main focus. AI can help, but ultimately it cannot make the decisions or produce the ratings or anything like that. So, Before we close out today, we do have 2 slides of practical actions that you can take away from today's presentation. So let's take a look. All right. So the 5 questions to ask your organization as you think about your own organization, I'd love for you to kind of use these five questions as a simple assessment. One, are managers documenting performance throughout the year?
This is so important. You guys just document everything. Are the expectations clear and are they consistent? Do employees receive regular feedback instead of waiting all year to get to that grand finale, the annual review? If that is a yes, I highly suggest please go back to your organization and try and, make strides, make moves to get some form of biweekly, even monthly type one-on-one happening. Are managers coached on how to have effective performance conversations? Remember, managers are not coming from HR backgrounds. They don't know a lot of the same things that a lot of you on this call do.
They don't understand and they could be new to their manager role. They've never managed people before. They've never been responsible for anyone else's, career day-to-day, things like that. So do they actually know how to have those performance conversations? And finally, is your technology making the process simpler or is it adding more administrative work? If you can answer yes to most of these questions, you are building a strong foundation for both better performance management and more effective use of AI.
I have so many clients right now that, and I'm sure Naya does too, that I am kind of coaching and having small trainings with the managers and then also having performance trainings for just the employees as well. And these are individuals that, maybe they're using BambooHR for the first time and they've never had like that streamlined process with those, same questions for everybody type deal. And it's new for them, and anything that's new can be perceived as scary.
But then once, we asked employees and managers, okay, you guys have done your first, performance review that was not waiting till the annual review, like how did it go? It was such positive feedback from the managers, from, the head of HR, and from the employees. Like, everyone said that they truly appreciated it and having that feedback with their manager and having those sit-down conversations.
And a lot of them said that they were totally lost before, and a lot of employees were— mentioned that they were scared to go to their manager to say, can you please tell me, like, how I'm doing, because you haven't talked to me in X amount of months and I'm not sure how I'm doing.
Nya James
So I've been in those shoes, by the way. Yeah.
Marissa Smith
I think we all have. And, before the role that we were in today, we were probably just starting in our career and yes, we were that individual being like, how the heck am I doing? So yeah, just some questions to ask yourself. All right. And then in the next 90 days, If you guys are wondering where to start and you're feeling lost, just focus on the next 90 days. So in the first 30 days, build the foundation by defining expectations, improving documentation, and identifying where that inconsistency is existing. And then, in the 30 days after that, help managers develop regular feedback habits.
And then use AI to organize information to prepare for those conversations. And then in the final 30 days, scale those practices by using AI to streamline manager preparation, support that coaching, and improve development discussions. So just remember, you can't overhaul your performance process overnight. So if you're like, oh my gosh, I'm not doing anything that they said, I'm not gonna sleep tonight. Tonight, because I'm gonna be doing all this stuff. Just remember, you can't do anything overnight, but you can build better habits that make every conversation more consistent, more objective, and more valuable.
Nya, I want to go to you. Do you have anything else that you want to add? Any last thoughts from the conversation that we had today?
Nya James
I love that you said it's not an overnight process. So if I could leave you with one thought It's be intentional. Don't just implement AI because it's available. It's a new tool. And don't redesign your performance process just because it's the latest trend. Start by building a process that people trust, one that's consistent, transparent, and focused on helping your employees grow. Then use AI to make the process easier and more efficient, not to replace the conversations that matter most.
So when you combine intentional processes without— with thoughtful use of AI, that's when you create a performance culture that more objective, and again, more human. Let's not forget the human.
Marissa Smith
I was just going to say, don't take the human out of this, everybody. Like, we are not ready for that yet. We need the human aspect.
Nya James
I was going to say, it reminds me of our CEO Brad Rencher, who just did a presentation at SHRM. The future of work is still human.
Marissa Smith
Yes, that was the most amazing message. And if you guys didn't have the awesome opportunity to see it or be there like Nya was, Go look it up, spend a couple minutes looking that up. It's an amazing speech. So, all right, everybody, we loved hanging out with you guys today. And if you liked this content and want more from Bamboo, please check out this resource, The Definitive Guide to Performance Management, and you can scan the QR code to get the link. And it was amazing being with you guys today. So we'll kick it back to Sarah.
Sarah Richardson
Thank you so much, Nya and Marissa, and thank you to our colleagues at BambooHR for today's excellent webinar. But I hope you all were able to take a peek at it from time to time. Lots of really positive feedback, people interacting. It was a really great chat today. So we appreciate you all. So we have a lot of great questions to get to. Let's see how many of these we can tackle together. And I'm just gonna pose them, and if you both wanna chime in, or if one of you wants to, we'll just— this will be super conversational, so.
Nya James
Awesome.
Sarah Richardson
Perfect. So let's start with this question first. I think it's a good opener. This individual asked, for organizations that still rely on annual reviews, what's the best first step toward a more continuous performance management process? How do people get started with making that change?
Nya James
Marissa, I think I'll start off and you can chime in. What I've seen, again, as an HR consultant, what we encourage is a manager-wide training. Especially again, you have newer managers who don't understand, what continuous check-ins are or coaching is. They wait for directions from higher-level leadership because they're kind of lost. So I say start with the manager training to encourage them to review the job description, understand what the essential duties are, and hold their employees accountable to the expectations consistently.
That would be one of my first steps is making sure all your managers are on the same page. Even if it's your most tenured leaders, they may still be stuck in a performance process from 20 years ago. So let's make sure all our managers are on the same page.
Marissa Smith
Yeah, and I'll tap in there too. One of the companies that I started was still operating from like 60 years ago, and it was, kind of crazy to go in and see all that. So I would say if you're, if you're just starting out, use AI to come up with five to seven performance questions that you're gonna have everyone use, right? Because just keep in mind, you want everyone to have the same experience and everyone to have the same questions regardless if they're in the C-suite or they're directors or they're VPs or they're just base-level employees.
Everyone should be getting the same few questions, and that'll help with your reporting too, to really be able to look at everything and assess it and see who's standing out and who's not. And so just come up with those questions and, have some of the members of the manager team sit down and just review the questions. And if you agree, just start there. And then that way you can give all those managers the same few questions to start asking their employees, and that'll help too for them not to get off track and B, maybe letting bias sneak in because they're asking three out of the six employees different questions.
And yeah, just, it doesn't hurt to just start somewhere, and AI can help.
Sarah Richardson
Yes, I like both of those recommendations. And we did get a few questions surrounding bias, so I'm glad that you tapped into that too, Marissa. Thank you both. I thought this question was really interesting, so let's do this one next. This individual asks, a lot of times I see employees have a hard time sharing feedback upwards. How, if at all, can AI help employees provide feedback/reviews for their managers? Do you have any insights on that?
Nya James
I would say for me personally, I don't know if this is controversial, but I also like to use AI to check my tone. Am I being too direct or combative that I'm not giving effective feedback? I like to ask—totally—prompting is important with AI, or otherwise you'll just get a very robotic response, but I like to say, hey, this is some of the feedback I have for my manager. Here are positive and negative feedback. How can I deliver this clearly and concisely without sounding defensive? That's one of my favorite uses.
Marissa Smith
Yeah. And I do feel like asking an employee to give upward feedback on their manager can be super scary because a lot of employees, if they don't trust the organization and they don't trust the manager, they're automatically going to say, okay, if I submit this feedback, it's going to be retaliation against me and I'm going to lose job duties, or they're going to pile on more work for me is going to happen. And so I always just say, put the fear to the side and just be completely open and honest because at the end of the day, we all want the same thing. We all want open and honest and transparent feedback.
So if that's what you're wanting, your manager most likely is going to want it too. So again, use AI to check your tone and make sure it's coming from a good place. And then I would say it'll be used positively.
Nya James
And I would say one last thing, an effective manager is going to want the feedback. As a leader, I wanted the good, bad, and ugly. Tell me I'm the worst and I'm not checking in. Like, yeah, it only improves my performance. So again, like Marissa said, put it to the side. And it's about development for the employee, but your manager as well.
Sarah Richardson
I couldn't agree more. I think transparency is key. I think it makes us all better performers, right? Thank you both for those responses. So we've received several questions about manager resistance to performance management. So this question says, how can HR help managers see ongoing performance conversations as a core leadership responsibility rather than an administrative burden? Especially when they feel like it's just one more task on an already full plate. That's kind of hard. What do you all, what do you say about that?
Marissa Smith
So this was one of my clients, and this was recently, so I feel like I have a good example. When I met with the head of HR for this company, we were implementing performance in Bamboo for the first time. They had a different process, and it wasn't working for them. So we came up with a whole new process, we came up with those trainings. Like I mentioned earlier, there was a manager training and then an employee training. So we separated the two and rolled it out. When we first started doing the training, a lot of managers pushed back, and I had to remind, the head of HR.
I said, you know what, this is going to be so eye-opening for you because this is going to set apart the good managers and the not good managers, the managers that should be in a manager role and the ones who shouldn't. And, like, yes, they can feel all of these things, but you need to push forward with this. Like, you— this is your decision, this is your choice as an organization, and they either are going to follow it or they're going to fail and be left behind.
And so basically, we went forward with it, and that exact thing happened, is the managers that weren't having those one-on-one conversations, they had no idea how their employees had been doing because they didn't take the time to check in with their employees, which led to why they were so nervous and worried about rolling out the performance process as a whole. And so that was very apparent, and I had to say, you know what, you have a lot of people that are not in the right role.
And because we did this, now you can kind of do a reorg and find the right people that are gonna have empathy and are gonna be able to sit down with their employees and do the coaching, do the training, be a part of their career advancement. And so I would say, like, if that's happening, you're gonna find out a lot in that performance management piece. And I don't know, Nye, if you have anything to add, but I have seen that so much. So just keep that in mind.
Nya James
No, Marissa, you said everything great. One thing I would add just from the HR or, C-suite level, share those statistics that, performance management or lack of development opportunities affects retention or increased turnover. What we've seen is managers who don't buy into the process, they have higher turnover of their teams versus others. So make that clear to them. Let them see the effects of it and the impact on employees. Also, again, upward feedback gives them that visibility, like, hey, this actually matters. This impacts my day-to-day and my success in my role.
And something I talked about in the chat is if there's still resistance after all the support, after showing the impact, then it could be a fit, a fit issue that they're not fit to be a leader just yet, or they need more leadership development training.
Marissa Smith
Yeah.
Sarah Richardson
Responses were incredibly helpful. Helpful. Thank you both. We received several questions similar to this one. So let's do this one next. It says, what are some best practices for driving meaningful performance conversations when they aren't linked to annual raises, or maybe it's just like a minimal raise, right? Do you have any advice as far as that goes?
Marissa Smith
I'll just say, at every company I've worked at in the last few years, and right now working at Bamboo, we have biweekly one-on-ones. Ones with our manager. And so we're constantly having those conversations and it is not linked to any increase or anything like that. And I would say that, that's a, that's a company decision.
Sometimes if you're gonna have the bi-weeklies or the weekly check-ins and then you have a 6-month performance review and then you have your annual review, most of the time it's at the annual review that either you can get an increase or not get an increase, but that's also for the manager to set that expectation with the employee from the get-go and let them know, like, these are conversations to hopefully help you grow into the role that you want to be. It's not going to guarantee that at your annual review you're going to get an increase or a title change. That needs to be earned.
And so that's why I think that those one-on-ones are so valuable because they're able to track where they're at that entire time. So that employee should know, okay, my last seven reviews, my last seven reviews have been positive. That's great. I've been like going above and beyond my expectations. But just let them know that it doesn't necessarily mean that the company can afford to give every single employee that increase. But it also, you can present it in a way that If the company can't give increases, if they're wanting to move up, give them an added responsibility.
Be like, you've been doing so amazing the last eight months. I think you're ready for this and this, and that's gonna show this and this. you can give them those other added duties without giving them the increase.
Nya James
So yeah. And one thing I would add in those one-on-one conversations, what I like to do was to find what the employees find valuable other than just compensation increases. Hey, I've always wanted a leadership opportunity, but I haven't been able to get those skills. So let's give you those stretch opportunities that are just as rewarding as, a small pay bump. Let's help develop those skills, and eventually those skills can lead to a larger role or a bigger pay increase.
Sarah Richardson
Thank you both. Great advice. I think it's a good one to close on. It says, if you could recommend just one change that would have the biggest impact on improving performance management, what would it be? I know we talked about a lot of good ideas throughout this entire webinar, so it's a hard one to just focus on one, but what would you all say?
Nya James
Oh, I would say a defined process earlier than at the end of the review cycle. Start thinking about it at the beginning of the review cycle. Start defining what those company values that you wanna evaluate, position values, have those documented so you're ready to present them. Because if you at the top are confused or, rolling out a process that you're not confident in, it's gonna trickle down to the rest of the org. Yep.
Marissa Smith
And just emphasizing on our words for the day, transparency and trust. If you have transparency and trust going on, it's gonna help the organization. It's going to help the individuals. It's going to help the managers. It's going to help everyone. So transparency and trust, 100%.
Sarah Richardson
Wonderful. Thank you both for those great responses. Thank you again, Nya, Marissa, BambooHR. Great presentation, very thoughtful responses. We always love having you all here. We hope that you'll come back and do another webinar with us again in the near future. So we appreciate you all.
Nya James
Thank you for having us, Sarah.
Marissa Smith
Yeah, of course.
Sarah Richardson
Our pleasure.