Tax Season Survival Guide: How to Navigate New Changes

Payroll changes can leave employees with questions and HR with a lot to explain. Join Audrey Arrington, Senior Product Marketing Manager at BambooHR, and Colleen Rynne, Senior Manager of Payroll Services Compliance at BambooHR, for practical ways to prepare for tax season. Explore federal and state changes, payroll reporting, and clear communication that helps employees understand their pay.

Key takeaways:

Webinar Transcript

Sarah Richardson

Welcome to HRCI Insights. This webinar series provides insights on current HR services, developments, and technologies. Our sponsors make these learning opportunities possible. While they may share brief insights about their solutions, the focus is always on valuable educational content. My name is Sarah Richardson, and I'm the manager of business development and partnerships here at HRCI. Our topic is HR's Guide to Getting Through Tax Season: Managing Changes with Confidence. I'm excited to introduce our speakers, Audrey Arrington and Colleen Rynne. Audrey is a senior product marketing manager at BambooHR, where she bridges HR technology with the realities of the job site.

Formerly a marketing communications manager for John Deere's Construction and Forestry Division, she led go-to-market strategies for construction equipment across the US and Canada, including media campaigns, public relations, and the division's first influencer program. At BambooHR, Audrey draws on her construction background to lead marketing initiatives for BambooHR Payroll, connecting product storytelling to real-world industry challenges. Colleen is the senior manager of payroll services compliance at BambooHR. With over a decade of experience in the payroll and HR tech industry and a legal background as a licensed attorney in Florida and North Carolina, she specializes in helping organizations navigate complex regulatory changes with confidence.

Prior to joining BambooHR, she held senior compliance roles at UKG and Ultimate Kronos Group. Audrey and Colleen, it's wonderful to have you both here. I'll turn it over to you.

Audrey Arrington

Let's dive into HR's guide to getting through tax season. We have two resources to share. The first focuses on tax season, and you can access it using the QR code. One thing to note: this session provides general guidance, not legal or tax advice. Make sure you're consulting with your tax advisors. There are many regulations evolving, and there are probably nuances specific to your business, so validate the information with your own tax advisor. The second resource is our state-by-state guide, which Colleen authored. You can access it by scanning the QR code. It gets regularly updated and is helpful for 2026. We want to acknowledge that this tax season might feel challenging because there's a lot going on. Hopefully this session will help with future tax seasons, quarterly reporting, and questions you need to answer throughout the year.

Let's start with why this year might feel more challenging. First, there were mid-year federal changes, which can create reporting gaps or inconsistencies as you bridge the two halves of the year. Your payroll system might not always be designed to adjust retroactively. At BambooHR, we try to be mindful of helping with those adjustments. If you have a different payroll provider, check whether your system handles them retroactively or whether you'll need workarounds to stay compliant. Employees might also be more aware of the changes and come to you with questions about discrepancies. State-level differences can create a bigger administrative burden, particularly when your workforce spans multiple states or includes remote employees. HR is becoming the front line for interpreting and explaining these changes.

Colleen, based on what you know in this space, what's the most challenging part? Is it the mid-year changes, or changes at both the federal and state levels?

Colleen Rynne

I think the most challenging part is those mid-year changes at both the federal and state levels. Employees may ask, 'Is my withholding accurate? Why is this much being withheld? Is my paycheck correct?' Even when payroll is compliant and correct, it can look inconsistent to employees if a change occurs mid-year. If they've been seeing a certain amount taken out for a state or local tax and that changes, they're going to have questions. If your employer has locations in a variety of states, you're juggling different rules, the timing of those changes, and communications that may need to go to employees. HR and Payroll aren't just processing payroll. They're explaining change clearly and consistently.

Audrey Arrington

We want to spend a few minutes talking about the federal changes you should be aware of for 2026. Let's start with the SECURE Act 2.0 changes, including automatic enrollment. Colleen will walk us through these, including what to keep in mind about catch-up contributions.

Colleen Rynne

Thanks, Audrey. The SECURE Act 2.0 isn't just one change you've had to monitor. It's a series of changes with different effective dates. For HR and Payroll, the practical lens is what creates a payroll deduction or reporting change. First, if you're establishing a new 401(k) or 403(b) plan, automatic enrollment may be required. Confirm with your provider whether you're in scope and what payroll setup is needed for automatic enrollment. There are expanded access options to retirement plans, such as emergency withdrawals. Those are more about employee education and plan administration, but they can still drive questions you may be expected to answer. Third, catch-up contributions and Roth catch-up rules can affect how deductions are coded. Make sure Benefits and Payroll are aligned.

Map what applies to your plan, confirm effective dates with your provider, and test payroll deductions and reporting. I also want to call out an important interplay between increased catch-up contributions and Roth catch-up contributions. The Roth catch-up contributions came into effect in 2026. If your plan has the optional provision for increased catch-up contributions for employees aged 60 to 63, there's an interplay. If those employees made more than $150,000 in the prior year, 2025, those increased contribution amounts will need to be Roth. That isn't necessarily explicitly called out in the SECURE Act 2.0, but it should be acknowledged as part of your compliance plan.

Audrey Arrington

Now let's talk about the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, or OB3. It has a few different names. Let's get clearer on the tips and certain overtime updates related to it. We know this applies retroactively to January 1. Colleen, can you talk us through the specifics on tips?

Colleen Rynne

There are a lot of questions about 'no tax on tips' and 'no tax on overtime.' For the tips provision, the deduction is limited to employees in occupations that regularly and customarily earn tips. The IRS has released a draft list of occupations and is working toward finalizing it. I feel like every few weeks I get a notification that it's at the White House for final review, but we're still waiting for the final list. For tips to qualify for the deduction, they must be voluntarily paid, with the amount determined by the customer. Tips received in a tip pool qualify, but mandatory charges aren't qualified tips. The IRS granted relief for 2025 regarding qualified-tip reporting. Employers didn't need to report the amount of qualified tips on the W-2.

The IRS said employees could deduct what's reported in Box 7 of the W-2, even if that amount might not be qualified.

Audrey Arrington

There are two parts to this bill, so we also want to acknowledge the overtime rules. Colleen, I'll let you talk us through that piece.

Colleen Rynne

The overtime part is the trickier part of these provisions. It allows employees to claim a deduction of up to $12,500 of the overtime premium. That's the 0.5 part of overtime. As a basic example, if an employee earns $10 an hour and $15 in overtime, the additional $5 is the premium and is what can be deducted, rather than the full $15 overtime rate. For 2025, the IRS provided administrative relief for overtime reporting, similar to the relief for tip reporting. For 2025 only, employers weren't penalized for not providing a separate accounting of overtime, particularly because this was a mid-year change and their systems weren't set up for this reporting. I think the IRS also needed additional time to prepare. But the IRS recommended that employers try to provide that information because employees could still claim the deduction.

For 2026, employers will need to report qualified overtime on the W-2. The IRS has revised the W-2 to account for OB3. Employers need to become familiar with the new W-2, report new codes for qualified overtime and qualified tips, and include Treasury Tipped Occupation Codes if they're reporting qualified tips. Reach out to your payroll service provider to confirm they're aware of the W-2 changes and will have them in place for year-end reporting.

Audrey Arrington

Why are employees and employers confused? There's a new focus on tracking qualified overtime, W-2 changes from year to year, and mid-year legislation that led the IRS to allow more flexibility. There may be mismatches between employee expectations and reported data, as well as inconsistent communication. Colleen, how are you seeing companies handle these points of confusion? What's working, and what isn't?

Colleen Rynne

OB3 is a great example of the confusion that occurs with mid-year changes. It also highlights the role Payroll plays with employees. OB3 passed in July 2025, but the no-tax-on-tips and overtime provisions were retroactive to January 1, 2025. Because of that retroactive application, employers didn't have the data to show which hours were qualified overtime and which tips were qualified. The IRS didn't update the 2025 W-2 forms to include that information. First, there's confusion because the provisions are called 'no tax on tips' and 'no tax on overtime,' but taxes are still being taken out on tips and overtime. When it comes to W-2 or year-end reporting, employees may have expected to find their qualified tips and overtime clearly identified, but that isn't easy to find. I saw a variety of approaches.

Some employers went back to their 2025 data to calculate how much was qualified. Some said, 'This is what we have regarding your overtime hours, and it may or may not be qualified.' Others told employees it was up to them to figure it out. There can be mismatched expectations, a lot of questions to HR and Payroll, and inconsistency across employers. Your employees could be talking to someone at a different organization that handled it differently than your business.

Audrey Arrington

Let's dive into how this shows up for employees and HR. It may show up in documentation, reporting, or the definition of qualified overtime. Shared data may be incomplete or based on estimates. HR professionals also have to translate between compliance requirements and informed employees' expectations. Colleen, what are employees noticing first: W-2 mismatches or paycheck differences? Where are employers getting tripped up the most?

Colleen Rynne

I think employees first noticed it on their paychecks because tax was still being withheld. I heard stories where employees assumed their payroll department made an error by taking out tax when it shouldn't have. But the tax is still being taken out, so employees aren't seeing the immediate relief they expected. Employers needed to set expectations almost immediately and communicate what this actually means. If employers provided a calculation of qualified overtime at year-end and employees compared that to the year-to-date overtime on their pay statements, that's another layer of confusion. If you're in a state that calculates overtime differently from the FLSA, there are more questions. Especially when overtime reporting focuses only on the premium amount, qualified overtime compensation is smaller than an employee probably expects.

As a payroll or HR professional, you may need to track different types of overtime based on your organization's location or a collective bargaining agreement, separately from the OB3 calculations. There may need to be some data cleanup so you can act proactively rather than reactively.

Audrey Arrington

What's ahead for Payroll and HR? There will probably need to be process updates, including new tracking processes for qualified overtime. Pay statements may begin showing additional classifications. You'll probably need additional reviews because of increased scrutiny of payroll accuracy and categorization. Questions will continue beyond tax season. Colleen, as these requirements evolve, how should employers balance system changes with manual workarounds? When should a company invest in new tracking infrastructure rather than adapt existing processes?

Colleen Rynne

My first answer may not be what people want to hear, but you may need to start tracking things manually if your payroll system needs additional time to implement requirements, or if it doesn't provide the full capability your organization needs. With manual processes, make sure you can control access, track changes, and reconcile against your payroll register if necessary. Investing in new infrastructure depends on your team's capacity and your organization's complexity. If you have a multi-state workforce, multiple employee categories, exempt and non-exempt employees, union and non-union employees, or multiple overtime rates, you'll want a system that can handle your needs. It could also be useful to track the number of payroll corrections, employee disputes over incorrect pay, and W-2Cs issued.

Those could signal performance issues on the team, but they could also signal a need for a new system because it's not calculating data correctly or handling your needs appropriately. To prioritize now, start treating year-end as a year-round task. A year-round plan can reduce errors at quarterly filing and year-end, and lessen mistakes during your most critical time.

Audrey Arrington

Let's shift to state-level changes. First, we want to talk about paid family and medical leave, or PFML. Colleen, can you walk us through the states seeing changes and why those changes matter?

Colleen Rynne

PFML, or paid family and medical leave programs, is expanding to over a dozen states, and we're seeing additional traction. Maryland passed PFML legislation a couple of years ago. After some starts, stops, and extensions, Maryland is on track to go live with its program on January 1, 2027. We're also seeing traction in other state legislatures. Virginia's legislature passed a PFML bill and sent it to the governor. It has not yet been signed, but the governor is expected to sign it and implement PFML in Virginia. Pennsylvania has a PFML bill that passed the House and is with the Senate. It's not known whether it will pass the Senate, but since it's passed one chamber, keep an eye on it if you have locations there. Other states considering PFML bills in 2026 are Hawaii, Illinois, New Mexico, and Arizona.

Of those, I think Illinois might be in the best position to pass, but we'll see how it progresses.

Audrey Arrington

What questions should HR and Payroll teams ask as they go through these changes? What reasons can employees take paid leave for? How long can they take it? What's the benefit amount? Which employees are eligible? Who pays: the employee, the employer, or both? What are the contribution rates? Colleen, what are your thoughts on these questions?

Colleen Rynne

I like this breakdown because whenever a state passes and implements a PFML program, it needs to answer these questions. It's a good playbook for HR and Payroll teams to find those answers and use these six questions to prepare for their roles in the programs. Overall, they come down to who can take leave and for how long, which HR wants to know. Payroll wants to know who pays into the program and how much they contribute.

Audrey Arrington

One last area we want to cover regarding state changes is overtime and tips. Colleen, can you walk us through what states considering changes mean for employers?

Colleen Rynne

Our discussion of OB3's no-tax-on-tips and overtime provisions applies at the federal level. State deductions are up to each state. Treatment won't be uniform, and these items aren't all at the same stage. Some states are considering proposals to allow deductions, while others have taken action. Each state needs to decide whether to conform to OB3, partially conform, or not conform at all. Partial conformity could mean allowing a deduction for certain years or amounts. A state could even change the definitions of qualified tips or overtime, although thankfully we haven't seen those definitions change. Often it comes down to state budgets. Payroll professionals may need to understand or track these decisions to anticipate and respond to employee questions. Use this list as a starting point.

Additional states are considering deductions for overtime and tips. For each state where you have employees, document whether it conformed to OB3 and to what extent. Is it a complete match or does it differ? When is it effective, and for which years? What communications do you want to provide to employees?

Audrey Arrington

Let's answer a few common employee questions and discuss best practices for addressing them. First: 'Why is my paycheck different this year?' Colleen, what are your thoughts?

Colleen Rynne

If employees notice a change in pay, they're likely assuming something is wrong. But there are several reasons the net amount could change. First, look at gross pay: hours, overtime, bonuses, commissions, or retroactive pay. If gross pay didn't change, look at the usual suspects. Was there a change to the employee's withholding form? Was there a tax table update or state rate change? That could be an unanticipated mid-year change, one implemented late, or a change made retroactive to the start of the year. Were there changes in benefit deductions or retirement deferrals? If the net pay change can't be explained by these items, escalate it or fix it now rather than wait for a larger issue to balloon at year-end.

Audrey Arrington

Question two: 'Why doesn't my W-2 match what I tracked?'

Colleen Rynne

You may need to reset expectations about what a W-2 is. It's a summary tax form, rather than a detailed earnings statement. Often nothing is missing or incorrect, although that can happen. Something may simply be reported differently from what employees saw on their pay statements or manually tracked. Provide IRS resources explaining how items are reported in the box or area they're questioning. That can also build trust. You can compare Box 1 wages with year-to-date taxable wages to ensure they align. Confirm timing differences between pay dates and work dates, year-end payroll cutoffs, and adjustments posted after the employee's last personal tracking entry. There may also be items employees aren't tracking that affect W-2 reporting, such as imputed income, pre-tax benefit changes, bonuses, retroactive pay, or third-party sick pay.

Audrey Arrington

Our third question: 'Where is my overtime reflected?'

Colleen Rynne

When an employee asks this, they're actually asking two questions: 'Did I get paid overtime?' and 'Can I deduct the overtime I was paid at tax time?' For the first question, the pay statement likely reflects overtime earnings, but a separate qualified-overtime breakout may not appear. Some employers have a separate line item for qualified overtime, and others don't. You may need to explain what qualified overtime is and how it differs from overtime under state rules or a collective bargaining agreement. You may still be working on how qualified overtime will be reported at year-end. Be transparent about your plan so employees know when to expect an update. If employees think overtime should be on a pay statement but it isn't, explain the applicable pay dates, why it wasn't included, and when they can expect to receive it.

Audrey Arrington

Let's discuss an action plan for implementing what we've covered. Communicate proactively before questions arise to provide maximum clarity. Build and distribute a centralized FAQ employees can access as needed. Train managers to handle first-line questions. Align messaging across HR, payroll administrators, and Finance. Document how your organization handles gray areas. Colleen, how can HR get ahead of these things?

Colleen Rynne

The overall goal should be consistency, so employees receive the same answer no matter whom they ask. That can also reduce tickets because if frontline managers give the same information, employees won't need to raise it to HR or Payroll. If nothing else, publish an FAQ and align internally on the wording. That can cut confusion in half. Everyone has the same message and process, with fewer surprises.

Audrey Arrington

Here's a wrap-up of your tax season survival kit. Review federal changes, including the One Big Beautiful Bill Act and SECURE Act 2.0. Audit state-level compliance requirements. Validate that your payroll system is ready for these changes and that reports are as accurate as possible. Identify areas at high risk for confusion and get ahead of them. Prepare employee communication templates so managers and other HR professionals have them available. Colleen, if you had to choose one item, which is most important?

Colleen Rynne

I would choose validating payroll system readiness and reporting accuracy because everything else depends on it. If your earnings codes, withholding logic, or deductions aren't set up correctly, you'll feel it at quarter-end and again at year-end. We've mentioned employee communication and consistency several times, but if the underlying data is inaccurate, you can't communicate your way out of that.

Audrey Arrington

If you remember only a few things, these are our key takeaways. Tax season isn't just about compliance. It's about communication throughout the entire year. Employees expect and deserve clarity, even when regulations are complex. Your role has shifted toward translating changes, rather than only administering them. As a reminder, the Tax Season Survival Kit includes resources to help with tax season. The other resource covers 2026 compliance updates, including the state-by-state guide Colleen prepared. You can access both using the QR codes.

Sarah Richardson

Thank you, Audrey and Colleen. Let's explore a few questions. Can you explain the difference between qualified and standard overtime again?

Colleen Rynne

Standard overtime is set out under the FLSA, the Fair Labor Standards Act. Generally, you pay non-exempt employees 1.5 times their regular rate of pay. If someone earns $10 an hour, that becomes $15 an hour. There can be variations in how you calculate that rate depending on the state. For instance, California has different rules about what can be included in the calculation. Generally, under the FLSA, it's a straight 1.5 times the regular rate. The reason to distinguish state variations from federal requirements is OB3. For qualified overtime compensation, you need to determine overtime wages earned under the FLSA, rather than state laws.

In California, you need to calculate overtime under California rules to pay employees, but also track qualified overtime compensation under the FLSA for the deduction employees can take when filing taxes. Under OB3, qualified overtime compensation is just the premium amount. If an employee earns $15 with the 1.5 multiplier, the premium is $5 an hour. Multiply $5 by the number of overtime hours worked to get qualified overtime wages. There's a lot to unpack, and it can involve tracking multiple types of overtime. This also applies to union employees. A collective bargaining agreement may specify how the 1.5 multiplier is calculated. Because that is under a contract rather than the FLSA, you may need multiple sets of tracking.

Sarah Richardson

Thank you for reviewing that. For companies operating in multiple states, what's the most efficient way to stay ahead of changing PFML requirements?

Colleen Rynne

I don't have an affiliation with any law firms, but I think they're an underused resource. Many send alerts and offer webinars. Follow two or three. You don't have to be a client to sign up for newsletters or attend webinars. They can be good resources for the details of PFML programs. Sign up for alerts from state agencies as well, such as withholding or unemployment insurance agencies. Some states tie PFML programs closely to their unemployment insurance agency, so you should receive alerts that way too.

Sarah Richardson

How can HR teams proactively communicate changes without overwhelming employees? Is there a balance?

Colleen Rynne

There is. It depends on your company's size. When changes come into play, determine whether you want to communicate them or document them in case questions arise. A retroactive tax change mid-year could create a lot of noise because many mid-year changes involve tax rates and withholding tables. You may want to document the response for that state in case a question comes in. If a change affects a large segment of your employee base, such as all non-exempt employees under the FLSA, it's good to have a centralized knowledge base they can proactively access. You're not flooding their inboxes or sending another Slack message. Instead, there's a place to see Payroll communications. Employees can find out, 'I'm non-exempt. Can I deduct tips or overtime? Does my industry apply for qualified tips?' Make it self-service as much as possible.

Sarah Richardson

You mentioned aligning HR, Payroll, and Finance. What practical steps ensure that happens, rather than just working in theory?

Colleen Rynne

You need an owner. When working across departments, have someone responsible for that relationship. Have identifiable outcomes everyone in the partnership is responsible for, and report on them to determine success. We've all seen something that sounds good in theory but never gets put into effect. Having someone responsible goes a long way. Report on successes and failures. Was quarter-end filing a success? Did any files fail, or were employees unable to be reported because of certain issues? Make someone responsible for correcting those issues.

Sarah Richardson

On change management and internal alignment, how early should HR begin planning across teams for the following year?

Colleen Rynne

Know when your busy periods are, because that affects when you can plan. If year-end is always busy, start those conversations in the summer. Once October, November, and December arrive, you'll be pushing meetings out because you're dealing with triage and emergencies arriving at your desk in the morning. You won't have time to discuss what's happening six months down the road. Start earlier rather than later. Also identify the level of change involved. For a new PFML program, such as Maryland's, start conversations early, even while the state is still ramping up. Make sure everyone is aware and on the same page about what will affect employees.

Sarah Richardson

HR is now the front line for interpreting tax changes. How can HR teams balance that responsibility without overstepping into legal or tax advice? How do you stay in your lane?

Colleen Rynne

I think that's a question everyone has, and the answer is specific to each organization. Some legal teams are very involved and want to be the front line for interpreting changes and requirements. Other in-house counsel teams are more hands-off. They may handle contracts or specific employee issues while relying on HR and Payroll to identify what affects the business and go to Legal as an escalation path. First, understand your relationship with in-house counsel and how they want it to work going forward. Some changes are straightforward. Depending on your organization, have a monthly or quarterly check-in with Legal: 'These are the changes we've identified. Here's whom they affect and how we're implementing them.' See whether they have concerns, especially if the team is more reactive than proactive or payroll-focused.

Also consider how well your legal counsel knows payroll or HR laws compared with contract law they may work with eight hours out of nine each day.

Sarah Richardson

If an HR team could implement only one improvement from your action plan, which would you prioritize and why?

Colleen Rynne

I'll split this into Payroll and HR. For Payroll, treat year-end as a year-round task. That takes some burden off at year-end. Year-end will always be busy, but doing everything accurately at quarter-end and throughout the year will lessen some of the changes you need to make. For HR, establish a partnership with Payroll and legal counsel. Identify the changes affecting your business and industry, and determine how you're going to communicate them to employees, or whether you need to communicate them. That's my top advice for HR and Payroll.

Sarah Richardson

I love that. Thank you again, Audrey, Colleen, and BambooHR.